In January 2017, Jordan Neely checked in at Bellevue Hospital in Manhattan. He was schizophrenic and addicted to the synthetic drug K2, and he didn’t have a place…
In January 2017, Jordan Neely checked in at Bellevue Hospital in Manhattan. He was schizophrenic and addicted to the synthetic drug K2, and he didn’t have a place to live. Bellevue treated him for five weeks but couldn’t offer much long-term help. One professional wrote in Neely’s file that he ought to attend recovery meetings—“to identify at least 2 triggers for substance use,” as if the triggers weren’t already clear. Eventually the hospital turned him back out to the streets.
Several months later, Neely, who was 24, showed up at Mount Sinai Morningside. He’d been smoking K2 and sleeping at a Popeyes restaurant before he arrived. This was a brief visit—but in the fall he showed up there again, after a three-week stay in another facility. He said he was suicidal because had “nowhere to live and no girlfriend.” The hospital fed him dinner then discharged him. Neely rounded out the year with two stays at Gracie Square Hospital on the Upper East Side.
Again he told staffers he was suicidal because he was homeless and had no income. The hospital ultimately recommended (among other measures) that Neely “attend daily therapeutic groups,” hoping these would promote “stable mood, optimistic thinking and compliance with treatment.” Again it sent him “home.” These experiences were typical of what Neely went through every year. And yet he managed to survive for six years longer. If his name is familiar, it’s because of the way he died.
On a Saturday afternoon in 2023, he was pacing around on a subway car, ranting loudly. “I don’t care if I die,” one person remembered him saying. “I don’t care if you die. Kill me. Lock me up.” Daniel Penny, a fellow passenger who had been in the Marine Corps, decided Neely posed an imminent threat. Penny put him in a chokehold, wrestling him to the floor and not letting go for several minutes.
By the time Penny released his grip, Neely’s pulse was faint, and he was soon declared dead. Penny was indicted on a charge of manslaughter, and the case became a Rorschach test for how Americans thought about crime and mental illness in major cities.
This is a source-linked briefing. Read the original report from The New Republic .