Surely, should you (by which I mean me, a freshman with whatever the opposite of a green thumb is) find yourself in a room full of esteemed experts…
Surely, should you (by which I mean me, a freshman with whatever the opposite of a green thumb is) find yourself in a room full of esteemed experts on the history of plant-science at a talk on the study of plant intelligence, it is reasonable to expect that you might leave the lecture momentarily impressed by plant research on the mechanisms of carnivorous species or perhaps the emergence of mycorrhizal fungal networks.
But what if the attendees of the third floor Gilman Hall lecture on that cold November afternoon left the room pondering not some mind-boggling plant facts, but the complex nature of science communities in academia and the increasing societal abdication of human agency? On Nov. 12, 2026, of the Hopkins Department of the History of Science and Technology Emerita Chair Sharon E.
Kingsland presented a colloquium talk titled "Is the Study of Plant 'Intelligence' a New Paradigm for Plant Science or a New Pseudoscience for Our Time?" As the title suggests, the most pertinent points to be made at the lecture were metacognitive in nature: not about plants, but rather about the community that study them. "[Plant 'intelligence'] isn't a fringe movement in the way certain pseudosciences can be seen as fringe movements that come from way outside of the sciences...
These ideas are promoted by scientists, PhDs, who have had successful careers in science, [and] are faculty in science departments at leading universities," Kingsland explained. Thus, Kingsland takes care here to distinguish the field of plant intelligence from pseudoscientific fields like eugenics, which have clear social and political agendas. This doesn't mean, of course, that the field is devoid of those on the outside looking in.
Science journalists Peter Tompkins and Christopher Bird, for example - whose 1973 book The Secret Life of Plants created great public enthusiasm for the field - presented ideas that many scientists today, including Kingsland, tend to dissociate themselves from.
This is a source-linked briefing. Read the original report from Johns Hopkins University .